8 Pension Benefit Traps Boomers in Ohio Still Fall For

pension traps Ohio seniors fall for — Image Source: Shutterstock

Pensions were once the cornerstone of retirement security—but for many boomers in Ohio, they’ve become a source of confusion and costly mistakes. Whether you’re a public employee, factory retiree, or private sector worker with a legacy plan, navigating pension benefits isn’t always straightforward. These eight traps continue to trip up retirees across the state, leading to reduced payouts, missed opportunities, and financial stress. Here’s what to watch for—and how to avoid them.

1. Misunderstanding Early Retirement Penalties

Many Ohio pension plans offer early retirement options, but they come with steep reductions. Retiring even a few years before your full eligibility age can shrink your monthly benefit by 20% or more. Some boomers assume they’ll “make it up later”—but pension payouts are typically fixed. Know your plan’s rules before you file.

2. Ignoring Survivor Benefit Options

Choosing a single-life payout may give you a higher monthly check, but it leaves your spouse with nothing if you pass away. Ohio retirees often overlook joint-and-survivor options or fail to update beneficiaries after divorce or remarriage. Review your choices carefully—this decision affects your loved ones for decades.

3. Overlooking Cost-of-Living Adjustments (COLAs)

Not all Ohio pensions include automatic COLAs. Without them, your benefit loses purchasing power over time. Some plans offer optional COLAs at a reduced initial payout. Boomers who skip this feature may regret it later when inflation eats away at their income. Ask your plan administrator about inflation protection.

4. Failing to Coordinate with Social Security

Ohio’s public employees may be subject to the Windfall Elimination Provision (WEP) or Government Pension Offset (GPO), which reduce Social Security benefits for those with non-covered pensions. Many boomers are shocked when their expected Social Security is slashed. Understand how your pension interacts with federal benefits before you retire.

5. Missing the Reemployment Rules

Returning to work after retirement can affect your pension. Ohio has strict rules about reemployment, especially for public sector retirees. Some boomers lose benefits or face repayment demands because they didn’t follow the guidelines. If you plan to work post-retirement, check your plan’s reemployment policies first.

6. Not Reviewing Annual Statements

Pension statements contain critical information—service credits, projected benefits, and contribution history. Yet many boomers ignore them or toss them in a drawer. Errors can go unnoticed for years. Review your statements annually and report discrepancies immediately. It’s easier to fix issues before retirement than after.

7. Assuming All Pensions Are Tax-Free

Ohio exempts some public pensions from state income tax—but not all. Private pensions and out-of-state plans may be taxable. Boomers who assume their pension is tax-free could face unexpected bills. Consult a tax advisor to understand your specific situation and plan accordingly.

8. Delaying Planning Until It’s Too Late

Many retirees wait until the final year—or even final month—before reviewing their pension options. This leads to rushed decisions, missed benefits, and irreversible choices. Start planning at least five years before retirement. Attend seminars, meet with HR, and consult financial advisors. The earlier you prepare, the better your outcome.

Don’t Let Pension Confusion Shrink Your Retirement

Ohio boomers deserve a secure retirement—but pension traps can derail even the best plans. By understanding your options, reviewing your statements, and coordinating with Social Security and tax advisors, you can avoid costly mistakes. Your pension is a powerful tool—use it wisely, and it will support you for life.

Have you run into any pension surprises—or learned something the hard way? Share your story in the comments.