For many older Ohioans, pensions once symbolized financial security—a promise of steady income for life. But as rules shift and companies restructure, that promise has become more complicated. From misleading payout options to tax confusion, retirees across the state are discovering that their pensions aren’t as simple—or as safe—as they seem. Here are seven pension traps Ohio seniors keep falling into and how to avoid them.
1. Taking the Lump Sum Without a Plan
Many Ohio pension providers now offer retirees a tempting choice: a one-time lump sum or monthly payments for life. While the lump sum may sound appealing, it often leads to fast depletion if not managed wisely. The Ohio Public Employees Retirement System (OPERS) cautions that a lump-sum payout shifts investment risk entirely to you. Once it’s gone, it’s gone. Without a long-term withdrawal strategy or professional advice, retirees risk running out of money years before expected.
2. Overlooking Survivor Benefit Options
A major pitfall involves failing to protect your spouse’s income after death. The State Teachers Retirement System of Ohio (STRS) notes that many retirees choose the highest-paying “single life” pension to maximize income—only to leave surviving spouses with nothing later. Joint-and-survivor plans pay slightly less now but ensure continued benefits for your partner. It’s one of the most overlooked—and most painful—mistakes Ohio retirees make.
3. Ignoring State and Federal Tax Differences
Ohio exempts certain portions of pension income, but not all. The Ohio Department of Taxation confirms that while some public pensions are partially exempt, others remain taxable at both state and federal levels. Many retirees forget to adjust withholding accordingly, leading to surprise tax bills each spring. A tax professional familiar with Ohio’s specific pension rules can help optimize withholdings and avoid penalties.
4. Not Accounting for Inflation Over Time
Most Ohio pension systems don’t automatically increase payments with inflation. Retirees on fixed pensions can lose purchasing power. Without a cost-of-living adjustment (COLA), today’s comfortable income may feel tight a decade from now. Supplementing your pension with savings or inflation-protected investments helps preserve your standard of living.
5. Understanding the New Social Security Fairness Act Changes
Recent updates through the Social Security Fairness Act have eliminated the Windfall Elimination Provision (WEP) and Government Pension Offset (GPO)—two rules that previously reduced Social Security benefits for public employees receiving pensions. This change means Ohio retirees who worked in both public and private sectors can now receive their full Social Security benefits without offsets. However, benefit calculations may still take time to update, and retirees should verify their records with the Social Security Administration (SSA). Knowing how your pension and Social Security now align ensures you don’t miss income you’re entitled to.
6. Missing Deadlines for Benefit Changes
Ohio’s pension systems enforce strict deadlines for switching payment options or updating beneficiaries. Once benefits begin, most elections are irreversible. Retirees should review choices carefully and make updates before retirement dates are finalized. Failing to meet deadlines can lock you into decisions that no longer fit your needs—especially if family or health circumstances change.
7. Failing to Seek Professional Guidance Early
Pension decisions are among the most permanent financial choices you’ll make. Yet many Ohio seniors rely on hearsay or online calculators instead of expert advice. A certified financial planner familiar with Ohio’s retirement systems can model tax outcomes, survivor benefits, and long-term growth options. The right strategy can turn a limited pension into a sustainable income stream. Without help, even smart retirees risk leaving money on the table.
A Pension Is a Tool—Not a Guarantee
Ohio’s pensions remain strong, but they require careful navigation. Understanding payout structures, tax rules, and survivor options can mean the difference between financial comfort and regret. Don’t just collect your pension—manage it.
Are you part of an Ohio pension system? Share your experience or lessons learned in the comments to help others avoid the same traps.
You May Also Like…
- Is Your Retirement Paycheck Covered by COLA + Pension + Social Security?
- These Pension Myths Will Quietly Erode Your Income Over Time
- The First Few Weeks Without a Pension Check — And The Hidden Ripple Effect
- What Happens to Unused Pension Funds When a Retiree Passes?
- Should You Take Lump Sum Pension or Monthly Annuities? The Trade-Offs
Teri Monroe started her career in communications working for local government and nonprofits. Today, she is a freelance finance and lifestyle writer and small business owner. In her spare time, she loves golfing with her husband, taking her dog Milo on long walks, and playing pickleball with friends.
Comments