Donating to Goodwill or other thrift stores is often seen as a win-win: you declutter your home and help someone else in the process. But the truth is, not everything you drop off at your local donation center is actually useful or even safe for them to accept. Some well-meaning items end up costing charities money to dispose of, creating liability issues, or taking up precious space on limited shelves.
Knowing what not to give is just as important as knowing what to donate. Whether you’re downsizing, spring cleaning, or helping a relative with an estate, these are ten things you should never give to Goodwill.
1. Broken Electronics and Outdated Technology
Many people assume that a thrift store can refurbish or recycle old electronics, but that’s rarely the case. Items like broken printers, VCRs, fax machines, and obsolete computer towers are difficult to sell, take up a lot of space, and often require special handling to dispose of. Worse, they may contain hazardous materials like lead or mercury, creating liability risks.
Goodwill isn’t an e-waste facility. Unless your electronic device is in full working condition and relatively modern, it’s best to recycle it properly through a certified electronics recycling center.
2. Mattresses and Box Springs
No matter how clean or lightly used it may be, Goodwill does not accept mattresses or box springs due to health concerns. Even if your mattress seems like a generous donation, the potential risk of bedbugs, dust mites, bodily fluids, and mold makes these items a legal and logistical nightmare for secondhand stores.
If you’re getting rid of a mattress, check with your city or county waste management service. Some offer free pickup or have designated drop-off days for bulky or special items.
3. Used Undergarments and Socks
Even though clothing is one of the most common and welcome donations, used undergarments, bras, and socks fall into a different category. Hygiene concerns and store policies often mean these items are immediately discarded, even if they’re freshly laundered.
If you have new and unused undergarments in their original packaging, those may be accepted. Otherwise, textile recycling programs are a better bet.
4. Hazardous Materials
Paint, solvents, pesticides, and cleaning chemicals should never be dropped off at Goodwill or any donation center, for that matter. These materials pose safety hazards to workers, and improper disposal can lead to serious legal and environmental issues.
If you’re unsure how to dispose of them, your local municipality likely has hazardous waste drop-off sites or designated disposal days throughout the year.
5. Cribs and Car Seats
It might feel wasteful to toss an old crib or car seat that seems in good shape, but safety regulations for these items change frequently. Many secondhand stores won’t accept them because they may no longer meet safety codes, and there’s no guarantee that parts aren’t missing or damaged.
In many cases, these products are considered unsafe to resell unless they’re brand new and sealed in a box. It’s better to contact a local shelter or look for baby item-specific donation programs that can verify safety compliance.
6. Large Appliances
Goodwill locations often reject washer/dryer sets, refrigerators, stoves, and even microwaves due to their size, weight, and repair risk. These items are difficult to test on-site, pose potential electrical or gas hazards, and are rarely a good fit for small retail spaces.
If you’re replacing appliances, many retailers will offer haul-away services. Alternatively, metal recycling centers may accept them, and sometimes even offer a small payment in return.
7. Torn or Stained Furniture
That couch with the ripped cushion or coffee table with a wobbly leg? It’s better to fix it or discard it properly yourself. Goodwill staff are not repair technicians, and items in poor condition end up costing them money to trash. Plus, heavily used or damaged furniture can be a turnoff to customers looking for clean, gently used pieces.
In some communities, bulk trash pickup or junk removal services can help you responsibly dispose of unfixable items.
8. Personal Care Items (Opened)
Lotions, shampoos, soaps, makeup, and other personal care items, even partially used, are not suitable for donation. Aside from hygiene concerns, there are health and liability risks involved with reselling or redistributing used beauty products. Some organizations may accept unopened, unused toiletries (especially travel-sized items) for donation to shelters. But when in doubt, toss it out.
9. Adult-Only Materials
It should go without saying, but adult DVDs, books, magazines, and novelty items should never be donated to a family-focused thrift store. Even if the material is legal, it puts the store at risk for backlash, violates community standards, and may even endanger its nonprofit status depending on state laws. If you’re decluttering personal items of this nature, discreet disposal is the best approach.
10. Anything Wet, Moldy, or Mildewed
A bag of damp clothing or a box from a musty basement might not seem like a big deal, but moisture and mold can ruin entire donation batches. Mildew spreads quickly, and stores are often forced to throw out not just the contaminated item, but everything it touched in transit or storage. Before donating anything, make sure it’s completely dry, clean, and odor-free. If you wouldn’t wear it or use it yourself, don’t assume someone else should.
How Thoughtless Donations Hurt More Than Help
The intention behind donating is usually good, but poor judgment can have a real cost. Items that are unusable don’t just clutter donation centers—they create financial strain. Charities often spend thousands of dollars a year on landfill fees to dispose of trash donations. In extreme cases, they have to divert money away from community programs just to manage unwanted goods. When you donate responsibly, your items stand a better chance of helping someone else, rather than ending up in the garbage anyway.
Responsible Giving Makes a Bigger Difference
Before your next donation run, take a moment to research your local Goodwill’s accepted items list (which can vary by region). When in doubt, call ahead. Some locations partner with other organizations to handle specialty items like electronics or furniture. Others may even have lists of high-need items they’re actively seeking.
Remember, the goal isn’t just to get rid of things. It’s to make a positive impact. And sometimes, that means throwing something out rather than passing it along.
What You Donate Says Something About You
Donating is one of the easiest ways to give back, but not everything you no longer want belongs on a thrift store shelf. Being thoughtful about what you give and what you don’t can mean the difference between supporting a charity and burdening it.
What’s the strangest or most inappropriate donation you’ve ever seen at a thrift store?
Read More:
10 Hidden Truths About Donated Clothing That Thrift Stores Keep Hush-Hush
Why Your Donation Might Be Hurting More Than Helping – 8 Shocking Realities
Riley Jones is an Arizona native with over nine years of writing experience. From personal finance to travel to digital marketing to pop culture, she’s written about everything under the sun. When she’s not writing, she’s spending her time outside, reading, or cuddling with her two corgis.
Comments