The Saving Advice Forums - A classic personal finance community.

Get rid of my Car & rely on ZipCar, Public Transit, Uber, etc.?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Get rid of my Car & rely on ZipCar, Public Transit, Uber, etc.?

    Hey Guys,
    I live in Washington, DC. My car is paid off, it's got about 100,000 miles on it. It's a Volkswagen that has been good to me, but it's also costing me a pretty decent chunk of change per month/year.

    A look at the last couple years expenses (DC area labor costs for maintenance are sky high btw, and my VW with its turbo engine certainly isn't the cheapest car to maintain).

    Between October 2014 and today, I have only put about 5,000 miles on the car. Being in the city, it's rarely useful to drive. Public transit, walking, biking, uber, etc. makes more sense. For commuting to work, I bike, walk, or metro. I could drive for a cheap cost (free parking as its in the same resident zone as my home), but it's a bit silly to do so for just 2.5 miles in distance).

    However, part of the reason I have not gotten rid of the car is the fact that most of my family lives in the suburbs of DC, and while metro + uber could get me there, I often cut the travel time in half with a car. It also allows for more flexibility. There are times where I need to make a run to somewhere outside of the metro area and don't have to worry about how to get there.

    The other big thing I do is take trips. While I don't take a ton, I drive 240 miles round trip to Rehoboth Beach, Delaware roughly 5-6 times a year.

    I also like to take other random spontaneous trips, where I sometimes could get a ride, sometimes couldn't to small towns in Virginia, a weekend of skiing in West Virginia, etc.

    I've noticed full weekend rentals of Zip Cars can get expensive.

    2015 was an expensive year hitting the 100,000 mile mark. So I don't want to extrapolate out too much that every year after this will be at this price, but it does have me worried. A look at the last couple years:

    Paid Per Year for Car Maintenance

    2016: $3,104.80
    2015: $1,312.38
    2014: $397.70
    2013: $2,360
    2012: $2,506
    2011: $1,115.91
    2010 [Year Bought]: $294 (bought in May, so would average to about $588 in charges if had for whole year)

    It's important to note that I was paying midwestern labor costs in a small town in 2011 and 2012. That cut my costs WAY down. I also had some body work done in 2012.

    Other Expenses ($1,976):
    $142 for car registration in the city.
    $70 for EZ-Pass (highway toll roads)
    $641 in gas (shows how little I drive )
    $160 in parking
    $953 in Car Insurance

    With all costs this month included, I am paying about $423 a month to have my car. With zip car, the only thing I might take off my list is the EZ-Pass which could still exist even if I had a ZipCar.

    Using last year's maintenance costs though (and the same other expenses numbers - because I don't have as exact #s on 2014), I spent $267.66 a month on the car.

    ZipCar's calculator of course tells me I'd save money switching. But I'm not sure.

    Other important note: My car is valued at around $6,000 on KBB (private party sale).

  • #2
    In big cities, dumping your car for public and alternate modes of transit has some compelling numbers behind it.

    What you really need to weigh is the potential savings against two things that cannot really be quantified: Independence and convenience.

    Taking a spontaneous trip in the absence of owning a car can be solved, as can longer trips to go see family, weekends skiing, etc. But is the savings worth the hassle of lining up transportation for those events? -Versus just walking out to your car and turning the key?

    I could vastly reduce my transportation expenses if I joined a vanpool, or even took public transit (40 miles) to work. But I'm not in a position where I have to do that. Riding comfortably alone, in my own vehicle, being able to leave a few minutes early or late, stopping somewhere on the way home, not having to walk in the rain, dark, or deal with people on buses is pretty much priceless to me. I will own and drive my car until the day I am broke and dead.
    History will judge the complicit.

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by nonstopski View Post
      Other important note: My car is valued at around $6,000 on KBB (private party sale).

      Sell your car for $6K. Use that to fund your "Zip car "for years to come maintenance free.
      Got debt?
      www.mo-moneyman.com

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by nonstopski View Post
        Paid Per Year for Car Maintenance

        2016: $3,104.80
        2015: $1,312.38
        2014: $397.70
        2013: $2,360
        2012: $2,506
        2011: $1,115.91
        2010 [Year Bought]: $294 (bought in May, so would average to about $588 in charges if had for whole year)
        Define Maintenance? Those look more like repair bills. esp on a vehicle you have only driven 5000 miles since Oct 2014 and put out appx $4800. wow.

        Comment


        • #5
          Keep the car. If you are really only driving 5k miles per year then your maintenance costs should be low. You just did all of the 100k maintenance and repairs so I would hope that for the next few years you would only have to do basic maintenance (oil changes, etc) since you are not racking up the miles on other components (tires,brakes, etc).
          Gunga galunga...gunga -- gunga galunga.

          Comment


          • #6
            You can't put a price on the freedom of having your own transportation when needed. I agree with above posters these bills look more like repairs not maintenance. Maintaining a vehicle you barely drive should be super cheap. if the repairs have been turbo related I would suggest letting it warm up properly before driving. Driving it at least once a week maybe a couple laps around the block to make sure the turbo is staying lubricated, especially in the winter. If the owners manual calls for premium fuel are you using the cheap stuff?

            Some insurance companies will base their rate on your mileage. At 5,000/yr it should be cheap. I would seek out one of these deals. Is the annual EZ pass making up for how often you use the toll roads?

            Comment

            Working...
            X