The Saving Advice Forums - A classic personal finance community.

The Cost for Protecting Jet-Setting President-Elect Trump? Yuge!

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • The Cost for Protecting Jet-Setting President-Elect Trump? Yuge!

    Hope they convince Trump and the First Lady to come up with another scenario for when he visits NY. Sounds like a nightmare waiting to happen!

    As the soon-to-be first family sat down in Florida for their Thanksgiving feast, they were watched over by the core part of their new extended family — a contingent of at least 150 Secret Service personnel.

    And when Donald Trump gets sworn in as president on Jan. 20, that contingent will balloon to more than 920 Secret Service agents and support personnel in Washington and his hometown, New York.
    The price tag for all that security is already very big, or as the Manhattan mogul might put it, "Yuge," internal Homeland Security and Secret Service documents reviewed by NBC News show.

    Right now, the cost to taxpayers is more than $2 million a day, the documents show, a number that is sure to increase whenever the president or the first lady travels — or when the threat level rises.

    Meanwhile, the New York Police Department is already handling external security at Trump Tower, the president-elect's Manhattan home base, at an estimated cost of $1 million per day. "You put a price tag on anything around the president, then you're putting a price tag on his life, and that is priceless," Jonathan Wackrow, a former Secret Service agent who has protected every living president, including Barack Obama, told NBC News in an exclusive interview.

    Protecting Trump's family presents unprecedented challenges. First off, it's a big family — 18 members in all, including Melania Trump and her 10-year-old son, Barron, as well as four adult children, three of them married, with a combined eight grandchildren. The Secret Service has not had to protect the adult children of a president-elect in a long time, Wackrow said. Also complicating security arrangements is Melania Trump's decision to stay in Manhattan until Barron is done with school in June. Donald Trump has told his team that he intends to make regular weekend trips home to Trump Tower until his wife moves into the White House.

    So millions of dollars worth of infrastructure will have to be installed in Trump Tower to turn it into a White House North. "You have to be able to conduct a global war from the front porch — that is just the reality of the situation," said Terry Sullivan of the White House Transition Project, a nonpartisan organization that helps prepare the staffs of incoming presidents for the rigors of working in the White House. When Trump heads home to the luxury 58-story high rise on Fifth Avenue, the feds will also need to find accommodations for staffers in a building where a modest one-bedroom, one-bathroom apartment rents for $5,250 a month, according to the StreetEasy real estate site. "They would need at least a whole floor, and every apartment on that floor would need to be turned into an office," Sullivan said.

    New York Mayor Bill de Blasio is so concerned about the city's getting stuck with the bill that he's already been in touch with outgoing Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson, as well as with the president-elect's transition team, to ensure that the feds guarantee reimbursement. "I made clear to [Johnson] how committed we are to the president-elect's security, but I've also made clear to him that there's extraordinary costs involved and that we want to start the process of understanding what kind of federal reimbursement we can get," the mayor said recently. "I will be speaking to the president-elect's team as early as next week on this topic."

    Former Secret Service agent Evy Poumpouras, who was part of the security details that protected Obama and President George W. Bush, said she hopes Trump will reconsider at least his own weekend plans once he becomes president. "This is one of those situations where they really should have an honest conversation with him and just really explain to him that this is not a good idea," she told NBC's Brian Williams. "To physically re-create the security that exists at the White House in New York City, it's not going to happen." She added: "There's buses going by. There's trucks going by. When that detonates, that building is not going to withstand that blast."
    In a subsequent interview with NBC News, Poumpouras said that flights out of LaGuardia Airport would have to be rerouted so they didn't fly directly over Trump Tower and that the subways running below the building would have to be fortified and closely watched.

    "Routes will need to change," she said. "All the security changes to make this happen will cost millions upon millions." Then there's presidential gridlock. Any time the commander-in-chief ventures in and out of New York City, traffic grinds to a halt, and commuter chaos ensues. Three days after he was elected, Trump's motorcade forced the shutdown of the Lincoln Tunnel — a key artery connecting New York City to New Jersey — for 60 minutes at the height of the evening rush hour.

    Back in 2009, there was gridlock across Manhattan when the Obamas flew in one Saturday for dinner and a Broadway show. And while the first couple has been back home to Chicago numerous times in the eight years they've been in the Washington, they've spent only 14 nights in their Hyde Park home, according to White House records. For a taste of things to come, consider how Trump arrived Tuesday evening at Mar-a-Lago, his 126-room, 110,000-square-foot mansion in exclusive Palm Beach, Florida, for the Thanksgiving holiday. It was in a 45-vehicle convoy that included limousines, vans — and an ambulance. Trump's glamorous Florida getaway will also get a bit of a makeover.

    "It is the case that the Secret Service regularly upgrades a president's off-campus residence," Sullivan said. "Typically, it includes security apparatus and global communications." Trump will have to get used to having lots of unfamiliar faces around him all of the time. "Just think about you at your home tonight and four strangers just show up and they're standing in your kitchen," Wackrow, the former agent, told NBC News. "Secret Service protection is the most intrusive thing that anyone could ever experience. We experience parts of your life, but we're also there in those private times when things aren't good — family arguments, family loss. We're there when staff goes away and the military goes away. The only ones left are the Secret Service agents. We're there 24 hours a day, 365 days a year."
    That takes some getting used to. For example, Obama was told early in his administration that his protective detail needed four hours' notice to safely manage his pickup basketball games. That, at first, did not go over well.

    "It takes a little bit of time, and it takes a little bit of give and take on both sides," Wackrow said. He said that the Secret Service will "need to understand [what] is unique about protecting Donald Trump and the first lady." "If the president-elect says, 'No,' there's going to be a conversation," Wackrow added. "We're not going to just say OK. We're going to actually push back. We may have to modify, but we'll understand what that pressure point is and then work around it."

    The Trumps' trip to Florida wound up being a compromise on both sides, a Homeland Security official familiar with the operation told NBC News.
    The cost to U.S. taxpayers? Seven million dollars, the official said.

  • #2
    how many golf trips for owebama?

    Trump isn't taking the salary, so that saves $400k off the top.
    Gunga galunga...gunga -- gunga galunga.

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by greenskeeper View Post
      Trump isn't taking the salary, so that saves $400k off the top.
      One article I read said that he has to take the salary; if he doesn't want it he can donate the $ to charities, etc...

      since it was "on the internet" I'm curious if that article was right/wrong...

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by Jluke View Post
        One article I read said that he has to take the salary; if he doesn't want it he can donate the $ to charities, etc...

        since it was "on the internet" I'm curious if that article was right/wrong...
        That's more or less correct. The government cannot, buy law, employ anyone without paying them. So he'll still be paid the salary, but can do what he wants with it. My understanding that JFK and another president (don't remember) both donated their salaries to charity.

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by greenskeeper View Post
          how many golf trips for owebama?
          Not an Obama fan but securing a golf course is much easier than what they will need to do if/when Trump stays in NY.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by greenskeeper View Post
            how many golf trips for owebama?
            The secret service needs to secure any site that the President is visiting whether it be a golf course, a hotel, a college campus, etc. But there is a huge difference between doing it a single time and doing it on an ongoing basis. There is also a big difference between a golf course and a 58-story tower in mid-town Manhattan. There are retail stores, offices, and private residences there. As the article notes, there is vehicle traffic right outside. There are subway lines underneath. There is busy airspace above. Closing down blocks at a time every time the President comes or goes is going to be a traffic nightmare.

            I've seen the secret service in action securing a building when President Obama spoke at a conference I attended a few years ago. They don't mess around. The security is extreme. I can't imagine them having to maintain that level of security at Trump Tower for the next 4 years. I feel sorry for anyone who lives or works in that building.
            Steve

            * Despite the high cost of living, it remains very popular.
            * Why should I pay for my daughter's education when she already knows everything?
            * There are no shortcuts to anywhere worth going.

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by disneysteve View Post
              The secret service needs to secure any site that the President is visiting whether it be a golf course, a hotel, a college campus, etc. But there is a huge difference between doing it a single time and doing it on an ongoing basis. There is also a big difference between a golf course and a 58-story tower in mid-town Manhattan. There are retail stores, offices, and private residences there. As the article notes, there is vehicle traffic right outside. There are subway lines underneath. There is busy airspace above. Closing down blocks at a time every time the President comes or goes is going to be a traffic nightmare.

              I've seen the secret service in action securing a building when President Obama spoke at a conference I attended a few years ago. They don't mess around. The security is extreme. I can't imagine them having to maintain that level of security at Trump Tower for the next 4 years. I feel sorry for anyone who lives or works in that building.
              I agree 100%. Honestly, I would probably move if I lived there or find another job if I worked there. Not just for the headache associated with each and every visit, but for safety reasons.

              Comment


              • #8
                Trump and his family needs to start putting this country first if they want to be our commander in chief. The wife and son needs to move to Washington and Trump needs to forgo all his businesses and put them in a real blind trust.

                Seems like Trump doesn't want to make any of the necessary sacrifices...should of thought of that before running for president.

                Comment


                • #9
                  I'm not understanding the point of this thread. The first of the "trash Trump" threads over the next 4 years?

                  The Obamas routinely took off for Paris, Africa and all kinds of places. They didn't have Secret Service? They didn't have staff?

                  Is the point that Trump should disown his family to make it cheaper?

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by frugal saver View Post
                    I'm not understanding the point of this thread. The first of the "trash Trump" threads over the next 4 years?

                    The Obamas routinely took off for Paris, Africa and all kinds of places. They didn't have Secret Service? They didn't have staff?

                    Is the point that Trump should disown his family to make it cheaper?
                    Uhh, or just move into the white house like all the other presidents.....

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      A) Security measures are not the same level of extreme for the first lady and the president's children. Still tight, but not "shut down the city" tight.
                      B) As stated in the article, Mrs. Trump & son will only be staying in NYC until the school year finishes -- 5 months delayed from the January transition. It's not like they're staying there permanently.
                      C) Sure, it'll be complicated when Trump flies up to visit with his family. But realistically, he's not going to have nearly as much opportunity as he might think to run home to NYC. If he manages to get up there more than once a month, I'd be surprised.
                      D) Setting up a security architecture in advance of the president's visit is certainly complex, but it gets easier with repetition. The Secret Service is going to make the process repeatable, and over time, less and less invasive upon New Yorkers. Why would they care? Because they always use alot of local assistance, and in this case, from the NYPD. If they make life miserable for New Yorkers over and over, they're going to lose the support of the local cops, etc. USSS knows this, and they work hard to maintain these relationships.

                      Seriously folks... the election is over. At least give the man a chance to start doing his job before you try to burn him at the stake.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by frugal saver View Post
                        I'm not understanding the point of this thread. The first of the "trash Trump" threads over the next 4 years?

                        The Obamas routinely took off for Paris, Africa and all kinds of places. They didn't have Secret Service? They didn't have staff?

                        Is the point that Trump should disown his family to make it cheaper?
                        pretty much, not even sworn in yet.

                        As you mention, owebama and crew were hardly ever at the white house, rather 8 years of campaigning for social justice and vacationing all over the world.
                        Gunga galunga...gunga -- gunga galunga.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by greenskeeper View Post
                          pretty much, not even sworn in yet.

                          As you mention, owebama and crew were hardly ever at the white house, rather 8 years of campaigning for social justice and vacationing all over the world.
                          Where do you get your vacation numbers?

                          Bush have taken about 2-3x more vacations than Obama, Clinton took less but by like 10-20 days less. Bush took 533 days while Obama was at 182 as of 2015. But if you think he travels to different countries for vacationing purposes then that sounds like an opinion to me.

                          Q: Is it true that George W. Bush took more vacation days than Barack Obama? A: Yes. Before his two-week trip to Martha’s Vineyard in August, Obama’s count was 125 full or partial days and Bush’s total at the same point in his presidency was 407. FULL ANSWER Our inbox is chock full of questions about who took more vacation days, Obama or Bush.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            The reality, which isn't bashing anyone, is that protecting the Trump family will be phenomenally more expensive than protecting the Obama family due to the simple fact that there were 4 Obamas and there are 18 Trumps. The Obamas all lived together in the White House. The Trumps will be scattered all over the place. There are more people and more sites to secure. That's just a fact. It isn't good or bad or pro- or anti-Trump. It just is.

                            As for the plans for Melania to stay in NYC until their son finishes school, personally I have no problem with that. I think it's the right thing to do as a parent. The next 4 years will be incredibly disruptive to the family. Why make it worse on the kid than it needs to be?

                            I think a bigger problem is Trump suggesting that he will be regularly traveling back and forth to Trump Tower. That's what I think is probably ill-advised and will cause unnecessary havoc. However, I also agree with kork. I don't think Trump will be making that trip nearly as often as he thinks. It will be far easier for Melania and Baron to hop on a plane and visit Dad in D.C.

                            And obviously, Trump Tower poses a very different security situation than what the secret service had to deal with with previous administrations. I'm not positive but Trump might be the first President who lives in an apartment building, not a private residence. I'm sure securing the Bush compound in Kennebunkport wasn't the same challenge as securing Trump Tower. There wasn't a steady stream of regular folks coming and going from the Bush property. Trump Tower is a public building. You or I could walk in there today to have lunch at Trump Grill or have a sundae at Trump's Ice Cream Parlor. Or you could be visiting someone who lives in one of the 270 condos in the building.
                            Steve

                            * Despite the high cost of living, it remains very popular.
                            * Why should I pay for my daughter's education when she already knows everything?
                            * There are no shortcuts to anywhere worth going.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by greenskeeper View Post
                              8 years of campaigning for social justice
                              You say that like it's a bad thing.
                              Steve

                              * Despite the high cost of living, it remains very popular.
                              * Why should I pay for my daughter's education when she already knows everything?
                              * There are no shortcuts to anywhere worth going.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X