The Saving Advice Forums - A classic personal finance community.

Someone finally listened

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Someone finally listened

    Sorry for the long post.

    So, let's be clear. I'm a minister, as well as work as a "system support specialist." Fancy name for IT Helpdesk. On the ministry side, I find finances to be a very taboo subject among people. There is a large mix of individuals who think "trusting in the Lord" and "God will make a way" means they don't have to save or prepare for retirement. I've even heard some claim that saving for retirement is storing up treasures in this world (not a good thing in the bible). I'm blown away at the excuses I hear for not saving. That is a terrible interpretation of scripture, because the Bible supports saving and even preparing for retirement. In fact, these are the same people who become a burden on everybody else because they are always in need and out of money(due to just spending everything all the time). It's just an excuse to not have to save. Gets under my skin!

    Ok, nuff of that.

    So, last night I was talking to someone who recently started pastoring this year. They are single, and adopted a child. They have a public job as well, but this is the first time they are filing taxes with the ministry income. They are pretty ignorant to anything money outside of basic paying bills, and saving a bit here and there. I explained briefly about how taxes will work with the ministry income, and how starting a traditional IRA might help pull the taxable income down if they were concerned about paying in. I also explained how a Roth works if they want to go that route. I assumed the help with taxes would be a better push to start an IRA. I also presented the idea (to cut some of the junk people think) that saving for retirement will actually allow them to be a blessing later as well as make them a better steward. I didn't think it could carry much weight, honestly.

    I got a call this morning asking more about it. I briefly explained index and mutual funds and told them to check into a Vanguard index IRA account. We talked money for a while longer, and I went about my business.

    Later in the morning I get a text "I just started a vanguard IRA account."

    WIN!

    I explained briefly how saving $200 a month with what they are putting in up front will give them $120,000 in 20 years with only $48,000 being what they put in(based on 8%). Then showed them how just adding $200 a month more on top of that will give them nearly double that amount of $230k. They are now planning to max out their IRA from here on.

    WIN #2!

    They are going to look more into all this, and I hope they do. We need more properly financially educated people in the ministry. I'm shocked and stoked that someone, especially in ministry, actually listened and took action. They are getting back $3,000, and putting in $2,500 into an IRA. I pointed out they are funding that IRA without any money out of pocket basically. That's smart money.
    Last edited by GoodSteward; 01-16-2017, 10:37 AM.
    Everything happens for a reason. Sometimes that reason is you're stupid and make bad choices.

    Current Occupation: Spending every dollar before I die

  • #2
    Great job!

    Comment


    • #3
      good work.

      sounds like a win.
      Brian

      Comment


      • #4
        Nice job GoodSteward!!!! I love hearing about those wins!!! Way to help others secure their futures!
        james.c.hendrickson@gmail.com
        202.468.6043

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by GoodSteward View Post


          I explained briefly how saving $200 a month with what they are putting in up front will give them $120,000 in 20 years with only $48,000 being what they put in(based on 8%). Then showed them how just adding $200 a month more on top of that will give them nearly double that amount of $230k. They are now planning to max out their IRA from here on.
          what fund(s) did you recommend?

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by Jluke View Post
            what fund(s) did you recommend?
            I actually haven't made it that far yet. I need to see what they did and adjust if needed.
            Everything happens for a reason. Sometimes that reason is you're stupid and make bad choices.

            Current Occupation: Spending every dollar before I die

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by GoodSteward View Post
              I actually haven't made it that far yet. I need to see what they did and adjust if needed.
              50% VMMSX
              50% VMFXX

              Comment


              • #8
                Thats great but now if the market goes south and they start to lose money they're going to blame you. Hopefully these folks view this as long term and to ignore the noise.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by rennigade View Post
                  Thats great but now if the market goes south and they start to lose money they're going to blame you. Hopefully these folks view this as long term and to ignore the noise.
                  I'm pretty sure markets don't go south any more. But if they do, I'm sure it will be someone's fault.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    you really are a Good Steward!

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by rennigade View Post
                      Thats great but now if the market goes south and they start to lose money they're going to blame you. Hopefully these folks view this as long term and to ignore the noise.
                      I actually touched on that briefly. I explained there is a typical 7-10yr pattern and not to freak out if the market drops. It'll come back up, just leave it alone. I also explained that one year they may actually lose money, but they are not losing shares. It always recovers, so don't worry.

                      *If it doesn't recover, we have a lot more problems than just a retirement account being down.

                      When dealing with someone who isn't already aware of all this, you have to be careful you don't overload them. I was afraid I did, but apparently not. They admitted to not remembering everything I said because I covered a lot of ground quickly. I am giving them a few days, and I'll go back and see what questions they have.

                      I will also help adjust the funds if needed. I need to be able to show them the performance, and explain why they want those funds. Otherwise, some "savvy investor/broker" may come along and try to brainwash them into a stupid fund that they will make money off.
                      Everything happens for a reason. Sometimes that reason is you're stupid and make bad choices.

                      Current Occupation: Spending every dollar before I die

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X