The Saving Advice Forums - A classic personal finance community.

Pay Off Car vs When To Buy?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Pay Off Car vs When To Buy?

    All,
    In a nutshell, here's our situation: we got married about a year ago, we both had saved some money (enough to do 20% down on a home), and we still have roughly $40,000 in the bank.
    Next year I'll get a pretty good raise. Not enough to compensate if the wife quits working, but it's a good raise percentage-wise.

    We're in a good position, but I was hoping from some more seasoned folks some advise on how best to proceed.



    I've set aside $18,000 as an emergency fund we don't touch. I also have some smaller savings areas (IE, tile floors, etc) we save towards also.

    I have $16,000 in a "New Car" fund.
    We currently drive a 2013 nice car, interest is about 1%, payments are low ($240), so it's not killing us. There's $9,700 left on it.
    The other car is old (2002) high mileage, we obviously owe nothing on it. It's probably worth $3,000.



    The dilemma I'm in is this:
    1) We both work now, no kid on the immediate horizon (When we have one, she won't work)
    2) One of our cars is old, while it has been reliable it's still old
    3) Occasionally, we need a truck. It's a pain to borrow one sometimes. Problem with trucks is they're $20k for a decent used one that's not high mileage or very old (2010ish model with 70k miles).


    I do not want two car payments under any circumstances knowing a kid will come someday in the next couple of years. One is enough- and I'd really like to get down to NONE.


    Would you:
    1) Leave it all alone
    2) Pay off 2013 car, and put that payment in the "New Car" fund until the 2002 car actually dies
    3) Pay off 2013 car, sell the 2002 car for what we can get ($3,000), and buy a truck with that money? ($20,000)



    Trucks aren't the best on gas mileage.
    There's nothing inherently wrong with the old car.
    Common sense tells me to not buy one until we need one.

    However, we are both working right now and in a much better position to get a newer vehicle that'll last us another 8 years. The old car (2002) in 8 years, it may still run, but it'll probably be a hunk of junk by then, too.
    Would it be smarter to get it done now (pre-child) or only when forced to?

  • #2
    You have $16K for a new car, so you're in a good position.

    I'd probably keep paying on the 2013, keep driving the 2002, and buy something when you have to.

    Do you plan to add any more to the new car fund, or are you going to keep it at $16K? You could put a few more thousand in it over the next year or so, then when it comes time to buy something you'll have more money to work with. Probably more than enough for a decent truck if you decide to go that route.
    Brian

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by bjl584 View Post
      You have $16K for a new car, so you're in a good position.

      I'd probably keep paying on the 2013, keep driving the 2002, and buy something when you have to.

      Do you plan to add any more to the new car fund, or are you going to keep it at $16K? You could put a few more thousand in it over the next year or so, then when it comes time to buy something you'll have more money to work with. Probably more than enough for a decent truck if you decide to go that route.
      I add about $100/mo to that fund right now. If my 2013 were paid off I could add more. However, I do suppose paying the 2013 off would knock that 16k down quite a bit.

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by bjl584 View Post
        I'd probably keep paying on the 2013, keep driving the 2002, and buy something when you have to.
        Agreed.

        A couple of thoughts:

        I a not sure why you would deal with the full-time expense of a truck if you only need one on ocassion?

        I personally would not replace a car that was perfectly fine. You can save up the money for your next car and be prepared, but really no need to buy it prematurely. The last time we bought a car our eldest child was 3, but it was money we had saved up *before* he was born.

        Comment


        • #5
          define "high mileage" on the older car.....100k? 150k?

          Can either of your vehicles pull a small utility trailer (4x8) which would in effect be the same as a truck bed for when you need it?
          Gunga galunga...gunga -- gunga galunga.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by MonkeyMama View Post
            I a not sure why you would deal with the full-time expense of a truck if you only need one on ocassion?
            Hence why I agree the "common sense" aspect is why I've not done anything.

            Originally posted by greenskeeper View Post
            define "high mileage" on the older car.....100k? 150k?

            Can either of your vehicles pull a small utility trailer (4x8) which would in effect be the same as a truck bed for when you need it?
            125k

            Not really, both 4 cylinder and must deal with putting a trailer somewhere, I think I'd rather continue borrowing if ever needed a truck than that route- also for what we've done so far weight-wise we use every capability of a truck.



            What about paying the car off now vs continuing to make payments?

            Comment


            • #7
              My general advice about trucks... rent them when you need to. Most things that people really need to do with a truck, you'd probably want to be using someone else's truck for it anyway. Examples being hauling nasty yard waste, trash, remodel debris, questionably heavy loads, etc.

              To pay off versus continue financing your newer vehicle...I can't give a good answer there. You've got the cash to pay it off, but at only 1%, it's virtually free money. The money could be doing other things presumably earning more interest, instead of going towards the car. Or, if you don't know what to do, throwing extra money at it on a monthly basis is a good way to go. That way, if in 3 months, you wished you hadn't paid it off, or something else comes up, you've only partially used that money to pay off the car.
              History will judge the complicit.

              Comment


              • #8
                This is something I have been struggling with. In the end I figured it would be cheaper to just rent a truck from home depot for 20 bucks.

                As for your question about paying off the car loan, at that rate I'd keep the loan.

                Comment


                • #9
                  If it were me I would:

                  * throw money at the car fund to bring it up to $20,000
                  * then throw money at the car loan
                  * keep driving the 2002 until the next time it needs a giant repair or dies or whatever
                  * buy a used vehicle for cash once the 2002 dies

                  I would also not buy a truck. I am anti low gas mileage for around-town trips to work and the grocery store.

                  And I don't think it's necessary to buy a car now, or to buy one before you have a kid as long as you have the money set aside to buy when the time comes.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by Spock View Post

                    What about paying the car off now vs continuing to make payments?
                    I don't see that it makes a difference in the end, either way. Flip a coin?

                    I personally really don't like dealing with payments. If it were me, I'd just pay it off and move on. It makes life simpler.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by Spock View Post
                      Hence why I agree the "common sense" aspect is why I've not done anything.



                      125k

                      Not really, both 4 cylinder and must deal with putting a trailer somewhere, I think I'd rather continue borrowing if ever needed a truck than that route- also for what we've done so far weight-wise we use every capability of a truck.



                      What about paying the car off now vs continuing to make payments?
                      125k miles is nothing if it's been maintained. A small car even with a 4 cylinder could pull a small fold-a-way trailer now and then....just don't plan to get there quickly.

                      Gunga galunga...gunga -- gunga galunga.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X