Well I know if someone gives a fiance a 30k engagement ring, they are liable for gift taxes.
Which means that a ring of any size is legally a gift.
But I think this is more of a personal judgement here. My opinion would be that if the guy breaks it off, girl keeps ring. If she breaks it off, she gives it back.
But again, that's only my opinion. Legally the ring is hers, and she can do whatever she wants to with it.
Which means that a ring of any size is legally a gift.
But I think this is more of a personal judgement here. My opinion would be that if the guy breaks it off, girl keeps ring. If she breaks it off, she gives it back.
But again, that's only my opinion. Legally the ring is hers, and she can do whatever she wants to with it.

. See
Comment