The Saving Advice Forums - A classic personal finance community.

Continue Paying Off Mortgage Or Budget For Home Repairs

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Continue Paying Off Mortgage Or Budget For Home Repairs

    Good evening everyone!

    For the past five years, I have been hitting the mortgage with nearly everything I got. In that time I have cut it in half. I have just recently refinanced the remaining $50k balance at 4%. My plan was to have the house paid off in another 3 to 4 years.

    During the refinance, the home only appraised for $70k, not the original $108k it did 5 years ago. I am not looking to sale today, but there are two home improvement projects I need to complete before I do. First is replace the garage doors. This will run about $1,500 to $2,000. Second is reside the house, which will be in the $8,000 range.

    The doors I am not so concerned about, I can just cut back on my lifestyle enough and budget it over a few months to pay for. The siding is a bit larger of a bite for me though.

    Depending on the month, I have about $20k at any time in the bank (not including retirement). So if I wanted to do everything today, I could, but it would knock a hole in my emergency fund. If I spend that much on siding I would love to live here long enough to enjoy it.

    On the other hand if I sale in say 5 years, I would then have 5 year old siding on the house.

    I guess the ultimate answer is cut back on paying down the mortgage and build up the emergency fund even more to cover the siding. Now that I have cut the house payment in half, I not as disgusted with the interest I was paying to the bank or the size of the loan. Also with the cash in hand, if I change my mind it can be dumped on the mortgage at any point. Does this make sense? Should I replace the siding now or wait till I am ready to sale? Should I save specifically up for it or lump it in my current emergency fund. My $20k emergency fund seems overkill considering it is 5 years worth of payments. Then again, the siding only looks bad, if you look at it!

  • #2
    If you plan on stayingm then do the work and enjoy the improvements that you made.

    On a side note, installing siding isn't really that hard. You can take a class on it or buy a book on the subject. Your $8000 job will turn into a $2500 job if you do it yourself.
    Brian

    Comment


    • #3
      unless the siding is not structurally sound anymore (falling apart) I would let it go for now.
      Gunga galunga...gunga -- gunga galunga.

      Comment


      • #4
        If the siding looks bad and is structurally sound, what abotu having someone pressure wash it and treat it with a preservative to bring some of the "new lustre" back to it.
        The garage doors, those may be another issue altogether.
        Sounds like you are doing a great job and are on the right track. I would think you could have the best of both worlds...
        enjoying nice looking siding, and continuing to pay down the mortgage.

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by greenskeeper View Post
          unless the siding is not structurally sound anymore (falling apart) I would let it go for now.
          I would say it is structurally sound. It is the fiber board type siding. The problem being that it is swelling badly at the joints, and also that the paint job isn't holding up. The home inspector told me 5 years ago that the joints were looking bad and that I should caulk them as needed. I have but it has only gotten worse. What has really pushed me over the edge with it though is a hole has rotted in the soffit on the corner of the porch over the past 3 years. A rather noise family of birds found the hole and moved in. I am going to give them a couple weeks to move on their way, then I plan on replacing the board myself.

          Comment


          • #6
            Why reside the house? If the current siding is doing the job. Leave it be. You can go broke trying to continually upgrade. Have it washed or painted and let it ride. I am sure you can find better ways to spend $8k. Personally, i am sorry i dumped so much into my house. Money i could have used to travel, buy fun stuff, etc. think about it.

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by myrdale View Post
              Good evening everyone!

              During the refinance, the home only appraised for $70k, not the original $108k it did 5 years ago. I am not looking to sale today, but there are two home improvement projects I need to complete before I do. First is replace the garage doors. This will run about $1,500 to $2,000. Second is reside the house, which will be in the $8,000 range.
              If you're really itching to get the siding done, why not open a line of credit on your home equity? It's a great option if you don't want to eat into your emergency fund. If you've paid off much of your principal, then you should qualify. For $8K, depending on how long you want to pay it off, the monthly payment could be as low as $50/month. As an added bonus, the interest you pay on home equity loans are usually tax deductible, especially if they are for home improvements.

              And for the record, I believe you should enjoy your home--not just live there. If new siding helps you achieve that, you should go for it. If you can get a loan for $50/month on your home equity, isn't it worth it, if you enjoy your home a little bit more?
              Last edited by BudgetMath.com; 04-18-2012, 08:17 PM.

              Comment


              • #8
                You don't need new siding. Pay off the mortgage.

                Comment


                • #9
                  If your going to be moving in 5 years I think you should budget for home repairs instead of paying off the mortgage (Or split it 50/50 -- so you can still save money on the mortgage). The equity your repairs will earn is worth it. Don't take out a home equity loan to make the repairs that is just adding bad debt.

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  X