The Saving Advice Forums - A classic personal finance community.

Which debt to pay off next?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Which debt to pay off next?

    Hello, my husband I are recently married and each brought some debt to the table. We have been chipping away at a $12K credit card balance for the last six months and now that it's almost paid off ($1,800 to be paid in full Nov. 1), we're trying to decide which debt to tackle next. We have the following:


    1. $2,664 on a 0% interest Rooms to Go credit card that we can pay off in equal installments of $46.00 until July 2012.

    2. Three months remaining on my 9%, 66 month car loan. Payments are $297/month. (The payments are on auto-draft and with only three months remaining I figured there is virtually no interest savings or any other reason to pay off three months early.)

    3. 33 months remaining on my husband's 7.5%, 60 month car loan. Payments are $354/month.

    4. $27,483 on an undergrad student loan that is currently deferred because I'm working on my MBA part-time. I consolidated at 3.33% fixed for 20 years, paying $157/month. At this point, I do not have to begin repayment until February 2009, although interest is accruing during deferrment and has been for a couple years.

    5. $131,585 principal balance on our mortgage. Our interest rate is 5.875% fixed for 30 years. The monthly payment is $767, and we have been paying that amount for 17 months, with 343 months left to go.


    A few other things to note:

    - We have NO emergency fund in place, as we've been pouring all of our extra cash into paying off that $12K credit card.

    - We have no kids and do not plan to for at least 6 years, if at all.

    - We are planning on keeping our cars (both Toyotas) until they die, so we are not figuring on replacing either one for at least 7 years. At that time I would like to pay cash for a used car. No interest and no new-car depreciation for us!!

    - We are 27 and 24. We each have a 401k with about $11K balance in each. We both get company match up to 6% (me) and 5.5% (husband) and we currently contribute only enough to get the full match.

    - We average about $2,000 leftover after bills, gas, groceries, etc. each month to apply towards debt/savings. This amount will increase to $2,300 once my car is paid off. So we do consistently have a nice chunk of cash leftover each month, but with multiple ways to apply it, we could use some help figuring it all out.


    Any thoughts? I know it's probably best, mathematically speaking, to leave the 0% interest credit card alone and just pay it off through equal installments for 5 years. Psychologically we would like to get rid of it, but I think knowing we can get an interest savings jumpstart in other areas would help, so we are leaning towards leaving it alone. Same with the student loan. I figure we can save a few hundred bucks by paying my husband's car off, but I wonder if the money is best put towards mortgage principal. Or, should we pump up our retirement savings by contributing more to our 401k's or adding a Roth IRA? I know an emergency fund is important too. We've been lucky so far and haven't had any real emergencies. Any suggestions or opinions are greatly appreciated!
    Last edited by MrsBaker; 09-29-2007, 07:47 AM.

  • #2
    If it was me, I would be going for the 33 month 7.5% car loan. It would be fun for me to watch that disappear because you can make a huge difference on it.

    Comment


    • #3
      Caoineag, thanks for your response. That's what I'm kinda leaning toward. It would be awesome to have both of our cars paid off, freeing up even more money!!

      Comment


      • #4
        You might be surprised at how much you can save by paying even 3 months off early. I know that most of the interest was paid early on, but the sooner that you start getting rid of the car debts, the better off you will be. Right now, you're paying for both cars over $650.

        I don't know if this helps, but one of my sons will only have one car payment going on at a time. When one car is paid off, they buy another one. I don't know what your situation is in that area. Definitely, get rid of the car debts as soon as you can.

        Comment


        • #5

          If it were me...

          I'd establish an emergency fund first.

          Then, I'd have to consider selling that second vehicle and buying something less expensive. That would be a fast way to ditch a substantial chunk of debt.

          The other car pays off in three months, so by the time you establish an emergency fund, etc. it is probably paid.

          The next step then, is to go ahead and wipe out that Rooms To Go debt. There is no good reason to keep that debt, which you want to be rid of, around for years.

          If I read correctly, that leaves you with the student loan and mortgage. At this point, I'd begin paying the student loan. It is a losing proposition to have interest accumulating while not paying down the debt.

          I don't think there is a single "way" to do this -- this is just my "if it were me" answer. Good luck!

          Last edited by poundwise; 09-29-2007, 08:01 AM.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by Aleta View Post
            You might be surprised at how much you can save by paying even 3 months off early. I know that most of the interest was paid early on, but the sooner that you start getting rid of the car debts, the better off you will be. Right now, you're paying for both cars over $650.

            I don't know if this helps, but one of my sons will only have one car payment going on at a time. When one car is paid off, they buy another one. I don't know what your situation is in that area. Definitely, get rid of the car debts as soon as you can.
            Aleta, thanks for the response. I hate our car payments! I will dance a jig of glee when they are both gone. I never want to have car debt again. Fortunately neither me nor my husband is the type to HAVE to have a brand new car. Well, maybe I was when I was 22, hence the 5 1/2 year loan!! Oh, if I could go back in time...I don't think either of us realized what a bad financial decision it was. I didn't even have a permanent job then. Ugh!!

            Comment


            • #7
              MrsBaker: Something that we do is to have a fund set up for a car savings, knowing that it is going to happen. I bought my car new in 1999 and I still have it. It has very low miles and I plan on keeping it as long as I can. It is over 8 years old and still looks pretty good.

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by poundwise View Post
                If it were me...

                I'd establish an emergency fund first.

                Then, I'd have to consider selling that second vehicle and buying something less expensive. That would be a fast way to ditch a substantial chunk of debt.

                The other car pays off in three months, so by the time you establish an emergency fund, etc. it is probably paid.

                The next step then, is to go ahead and wipe out that Rooms To Go debt. There is no good reason to keep a that debt, which you want to be rid of, around for years.

                If I read correctly, that leaves you with the student loan and mortgage. At this point, I'd begin paying the student loan. It is a losing proposition to have interest accumulating while not paying down the debt.

                I don't think there is a single "way" to do this -- this is just my "if it were me" answer. Good luck!
                Thanks! I agree there is no single way. I rack my brain trying to think what is the "best" way for us. You get into the math games...if I pay this then I save X interest, if I pay that I save Y. It makes my head hurt! You make a good point about the student loan debt...the fact that it's accumulating interest and I'm not making any payments...that's always in the back of my mind.

                Comment


                • #9
                  There are some on this forum who like Dave Ramsey. By the way, he's going to be on a new network that Fox owns and it will be for financial stuff.

                  I don't know how close you are to a library, but there are a ton of books there and they're free. I picked up the Dave Ramsey book there. He is a good person to start with. His biggee is getting $1,000. emergency fund established before paying off any debt.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    I would set up an emergency fund, even if it's 1000 like Dave Ramsey recommends. That way if anything comes up, you can pay for it and not put it on the credit card.

                    After that I'd pay off your car. Even though it won't save you much on interest on your car the extra $300 that had been going toward your car will help save a lot on interest on the 2nd car!

                    Then I would work on the other loans. I'd probably pay them off in this order: Rooms to Go, Mortgage and Student loans.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by Caoineag View Post
                      If it was me, I would be going for the 33 month 7.5% car loan. It would be fun for me to watch that disappear because you can make a huge difference on it.
                      but loans are not like credit card where you can easily adjust your repayments. they might be charged an early repayment panalty if they increase the repayments.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        I agree with Mrs Baker with a small modification... I would work on the student loan before the Rooms to Go loan. You have money for nothing there... as long as you pay your minimal payment, then it's a pretty painless loan. The student loan's interest should be addressed first.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Firtst, Congratulations to you! you have done amazing things already, you are young, have penty of time and will only do more and better once the MBA is finished.

                          If I understand it you have approximately 2000 left each month to do with as you wish. If this is true then I would do three things immediately:

                          1. pay off the car loan that is so close to being paid off @9% with one lump sum payment.

                          2. start an emergency fund with 1000 a month until it equals 6 months expenses for both of you.

                          3. put 1000 toward the other car debt to get it paid off asap.

                          4. Once the car is paid off, pay off the furniture with 1000 a month while still funding the emergency fund.

                          Once that is paid off and you should increas the 401 for each of you just a couple hundred dollars, put 1000 toward the student loan and get rid of it. then put extra toward the house each month. Try and pay it off quicker than 25+years.

                          good lukc, keep us up to date with what you choose and congratulations when you finish grad school. that we the best day of my life!!

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Thank you all for the advice. I really appreciate your opinions and suggestions!!

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Mrs Baker,

                              Here is an excellent debt reduction calculator. It allows you to input up to 9 debts, their interest rates, balances, etc, then you tell what your payments are and how much extra you can put towards them and it gives you a schedule of the best (quickest) way to pay them off.

                              Here's the site:

                              Debt Calculator Consolidation Solution Eliminate Credit Card and Consolidate Debt Calculators by Bankrate.com

                              Good luck!

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X