Is this a good idea?

**kork13** · 06-14-2009, 05:50 PM

Originally posted by limeslice View Post

I have a car that needs a lot of repairs to get it safe for driving. I'm not sure whether to just junk it and get another car or to have the repairs done. I was wondering if I could take it to a car mechanic school to have some of the trainees work on it cheap. Is that something that is possible? Has anyone ever had any experience doing it? Does this sound like a good idea or not?

Well if nothing else, it doesn't sound like a bad idea to at least consider. I've also heard of college/vocational/high school mech classes offering low-cost (or free) repairs. Make some calls and see if there's someone in your area that offers such a situation. Just be aware that you run the (sometimes significant) risk that repairs will be poorly/incorrectly done, or could potentially be made worse.

I would figure out out what the car is worth (to a junkyard or mechanic who would take it off your hands), and go from there. If only significant repairs will make your car drivable, it may be worth buying a good, reliable, used car for yourself and getting rid of your current car--assuming you can afford to do so.

**maat55** · 06-14-2009, 07:37 PM

Typically, if the repairs cost more than the vehicle is worth after the repairs, it is better to replace the car. If you have serviced the vehicle well, it might be worth a little more than bluebook.

Taking it to a mech school for evaluation is viable idea. I've never done it so I can't say how the process will evolve. Good luck.

**Brad VanGuard** · 06-29-2009, 11:20 AM

I agree, these are good posts. What you need to consider is are you going to be happy with the car in the future or is it one you will want to replace within a year or two? If so, then you might as well get a new car now.

Is this a good idea?