The Saving Advice Forums - A classic personal finance community.

Kids that don't want money! how to teach about finnance?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Kids that don't want money! how to teach about finnance?

    wierd title- I know. a bit long- trying to explain the situation.

    How do you teach the value of a dollar to kids that really don't care much about money??

    I opened up youth savings accounts for my kids - the wells fargo ones that have incentives for deposits. Every time you deposit 3.00 or more you get a little coupon. After you collect a certain amount of coupons, you get a little prize, like pencils, stuffed animals, ect. you can also earn a 25.00 savings bond.

    Then I set up an allowance system- 1.00 a week for each year of thier ages. for example, a 6 year old would get 6.00 per week. Then I set up a chore chart with roatating tasks on a white board. Each child was to check off her chore as it was completed that day. if they completed all the chores, it equalled the full allowance. ( 6.00 for all chores completed in the week. )
    these chores were extras beyond what they were expected to do around the house. They already have to clean thier rooms, feed the dog, ect. But extra chores included things like sweeping the patio, dusting the downstairs, ect.

    well the kids weren't remotely interested in any of it. they had no desire to make any money. they really weren't keen on the whole bank account and prizes. I thought I'd start simple, and as they saved and bought things we could talk more about interest, and debit cards, ect. there is even a cute girl scout program called Penny Power that talks about kids and money that I thought I'd do with them, they said it sounded "boring".

    The kids just aren't "wanters"---- they get some birthday money and jam it in thier purse and forget it. The tooth fairy came last week and left a dollar on dd's dresser. it's still sitting there, untouched. They don't see commercials and instantly want anything. they don't covet candy or sugar cereals. ( even though I do!) sometimes one will talk about wanting something and ask if they can add it to thier christmas or birthday list. My older dd had exactly one thing on her christmas list last year- a musical instrument.

    I don't feel like they are spoiled- , they take birthday money to garage sales to buy books sometimes, but mostly anything they get comes from thier birthday or christmas. they don't ask for new clothes- just whatever I find on clearance and hang in their closet is what they wear.

    I dunno- I was hoping to make money a teaching tool- to start up leasons about savings, charity, and some math lessons too like investing, compound interest.
    any advice?? What am I doing wrong? I want financailly literate children and I wanted to educate them about money before the teen "gimmes" come along. thanks.

  • #2
    Re: Kids that don't want money! how to teach about finnance?

    Huh. Your children are... wonderfully peculiar! I wish my kids wouldn't want so much material possessions, and just be content with life in general.

    Mine want stuff they don't need all the time. Video games and toys galore. Of course, I don't give them any money, including allowances (because they won't be getting that in the real world either). All I do is ask them, "And how would you earn the money to buy that?"

    With a little bit of guidance and coaching, I would point them the way towards some chores and jobs they can do to earn some money, and when they save enough, then they can go out and buy it.

    That's... basically it for me.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Kids that don't want money! how to teach about finnance?

      Not being "wanters" is a good thing, I think. It's the starting point of frugality, and at least they're not being sucked into the consumerist trap at a young age. So many commericals are targeting kids and teens these days--especially the fast food and tobacco industries. It's terrifying, really.

      Maybe resource management games such as Monopoly might be interesting to introduce to your kids?

      Or you might try what my father did. When I was little, I didn't care about money, either. My father started giving me a $10/week allowance in high school (never had one before then, and didn't ask for it). He also said that if I let him invest it in mutual funds, he'll match an extra $5. So I sat back and let him invest $15/week for me for four years. I ended up with a pretty chunk of change at the end of it. And I learned the value of investments.

      What do you think?

      ~mimi

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Kids that don't want money! how to teach about finnance?

        first congrats on some great kids!

        next......if at first you don't succeed try, try again... differently.

        monopoly is a great suggestion, life (the game) isn't half bad, or offer to let them plan and buy groceries for the week. give them the dollar amount stock up on mac n cheese n canned veggies the week before(in case you run out of food!), and let em try it (if you already stockpile a great deal this wouldn't work unless you cheat and hide your stock)

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Kids that don't want money! how to teach about finnance?

          I think its great that they aren't big spenders. It sounds like they are savers, but unmotivated savers. They don't know the results of saving...interest. That is why the bank accounts are such a great idea. Maybe you could at least reinforce the idea of tracking the interest earned on a chart. It might be boring the first month or two, but they will catch on.

          Then, of course, they need a goal for savings. Right now they don't appear to be wanting to save for current desires, what about future desires, such as a car...my kids are always on the lookout for VW bugs and love to talk about what color they will get!! Other goals for the future could include college, too.

          I'm not really one for allowance, but as a high schooler I was given $75 a month to buy my own toiletries, and use the money for football games, ect. But after the money was gone I had to wait. It was a good lesson in making your money last. I wish I was told I could save some of it...that didn't even cross my mind at the time.

          I wish you luck.
          My other blog is Your Organized Friend.

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Kids that don't want money! how to teach about finnance?

            I tried teaching my daughter about money too. I opened savings accounts for her, got her baby sitting jobs, cashier jobs, put 1/2 her money into savings. She was not interested and to this day has no savings account. I am glad your kids are not "wanters", that will helop. Maybe they will get more interested when they get to high school and you can let them pay for their own stuff.

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Kids that don't want money! how to teach about finnance?

              Don't know exactly how old your kids are but here is a tiny help...



              I have one saver and one spender still at home. One always wanted to spend and the other always to save. Some of this is just how we are 'bent'. However, having homeschooled mine they were similar in no wants for the longest time...they didn't have the peer pressure involved.

              If I were you I wouldn't give up hope but just keep seizing those teaching moments when they arise. You are in the store with two similar items..."which one is cheaper for us to buy?" and let them figure it out. When shopping let them hear you put stuff back on the shelf saying, "I'd rather save my money and earn interest than have this now." Stuff like that. There are lots of these kind of minute by minute decisions we parents make but don't often verbalize them. Let the kids hear your rationale behind monetary decisions. Over time lots will sink in.

              I like the idea of keeping a chart showing interest earned! I think I'll try that here. It'll show CashHappySon just how much better off financially Frugal Son is w/his investments rather than spending!

              Comment

              Working...
              X