The Saving Advice Forums - A classic personal finance community.

Buying or renting the next property

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Buying or renting the next property

    Hello,

    I recently moved to Arlington, VA (very high cost of living) from Virginia Beach (modest / low cost of living). I bought a house in Virginia Beach for 439k and it currently is rented out and is covering all expenses (mortgage, upkeep, PM fees etc.) and is pulling a small profit. So that house assuming everything stays the same - essentially runs itself.

    I moved up to Arlington for my job (same one, just less travel since I'm in the area closer to the companies I supported). I decided it was best to rent since I didn't know exactly what kind of lifestyle I wanted (26 years old, careers change, girlfriend etc.) The rent is currently $2800 a month all inclusive for a 1 bdr/bath + a den.

    To purchase a similar property in this area it would be around 600k (2 bedrooms, 1/2 baths, 1000 sq feet). This would require a significant down payment.

    I feel like I have to three choices:

    A) Buy a property in Arlington although I'm not sure how long I will live here and turn it into a rental once I move. If I do this I will pay less interest (primary residence) and I'll be able to write off the Interest on my taxes.

    B) Take the down payment I would pay and buy a more reasonable house in Virginia Beach (250K can get you the same property here and only put 50k down / 20% down and turn it into a rental immediately). I would then rent in Arlington again around the same rate.

    C) Simply continue to rent my property in VB, take the money I would put on a down payment and invest it. Continue to rent in Arlington.

    Option B seems like the best since I'd be investing in real estate, I tie less money into the down payment and giving me more flexibility if we want to move. The downside of it is that I'm paying very high rent for where I live when I could be investing that money per month into a property.

    I'd love to get your thoughts! It's kind of strange to buy rental property and rent personally but it seems like a good option here. Keeping in mind most mortgages are mostly interest anyway so rent isn't completely throwing money away (since I get something in return ~ a place to live without any risk).

  • #2
    I wish I could help, but I'm still trying to wrap my head around $2800 for a one bedroom apartment or a $600K 1000 sq. ft. house! When my ex and I first got married we moved into a new construction 1000 sq ft. house that was I think about $38K around 6 years later we sold it for $42K and currently it would sell for around $110-120K! I don't know how folks that don't make the kind of money that you seem to, can afford to live in areas like that at all.

    Personally I would really sit down with your life goals to see whether buying to rent or buying to live in would coincide with your goals and how the choices will get you moving towards where you eventually want to find yourself. You do have your goals written down don't you? Decisions like this shouldn't be made in a vacuum.
    Gailete
    http://www.MoonwishesSewingandCrafts.com

    Comment


    • #3
      Rent you probably will have too much tied up in RE without a balanced portfolio. You also don't sound sure about GF and where to live. Save and rent. Buy flexibility.
      LivingAlmostLarge Blog

      Comment


      • #4
        Agreed the rental and property cost here is out of control.

        I'm also leaning towards renting as well. Thanks.

        Comment

        Working...
        X