I have tried a soap-borax-washing soda mix and did not like it. I find detergents are much better. When detergents came on the market after WWII, people were very pleased with how much better they cleaned than their old reliables like soap. Especially if you have hard water or get very dirty (including greasy/oily) , detergents work better. However, most people now work indoors, in climate controlled buildings and do not really get very dirty anyway. So for most people soaps instead of detergents probably are adequate.
Remember the yellow collar and underarm stains of years gone by? Maybe you don't remember it if you are not old enough to remember that many people used to use soap products (Like Ivory Soap Flakes, already grated and ready to measure!). That is not nearly so much a problem for people using real detergents instead of soaps in their laundry, so I imagine there are many people now who've never even seen the yellow collars and underarms that washing in detergent prevents.....We may call our washing powders "soap," but nowadays the vast majority of them, even the very cheapest ones, are the more effective detergents.
The vinegar rinse is somewhat appropriate for hard water areas, the same areas where the soap mix works the poorest, and rinse out the poorest.
I don't have particularly hard water, but detergent works better for me and no vinegar or any softener is necessary. Sometimes I like softener on certain items, but I've had the same bottlefor 5 or 6 years now.
|