Quote:
Originally Posted by wincrasher
You can sit back and scavenge for a living. Yes, you aren't using YOUR money - but you are using somebody else's. I see no pride in it. I see it as giving up.
|
Exactly. The reason he can "scrounge" to find things is that other people get paid to make them, other people earn money to buy them and then discard them, and then he can find them.
The litmus test is: would it work if everyone did this? And the answer would be no, because there would be no streets of Moab Utah to scrounge through and find discarded things. You'd be dependent only on what naturally grew, and even then, the population would need to be spread so thin that they didn't overwhelm the resources available.
What happens if your cave is the best living quarters around, because no one is being paid to build houses, and someone else wants to kick you out and move in? Suddenly a person's right to peaceful ownership of private property would become a pressing issue, I bet. And from private property would come ownership of the means of production ("I spent 10 hours carving that spear head out of stone; no you can't use it to kill a buffalo unless you share some of the meat with me.") And then we're right back to a capitalistic society.
I think the basic idea behind it all is actually pretty good: be content with what you have. Don't tie your self-worth to what you own.
But it doesn't require adopting the false illusion of giving up money to do that. I've had people say to me, how can you live in such a small apartment? I'm always surprised. As long as I'm warm and safe and comfortable, why do I need more room? I've got the whole world to go out and walk in, if I want to move around more.
But that's wa-a-ay different than pretending I'm not paying rent to a landlord and working at a job five days a week to do so.