Flash, which article of Jeffrey's are you referring to? I did a search and came up with several. So far I haven't found one where he was saying coupon clipping services were carrying out illegal activity or saying not to talk about them. In fact, he has an article up called Couponing 101 by a Kim Rowley, which mentions coupon services. And he has a reply to that article talking about using Ebay for coupons, where he doesn't seem to have any qualms about it at all.
I'd be curious what law this falls under. See the 10th paragraph down in this article from the grocery industry point of view.
http://promomagazine.com/othertactic...coupon_crimes/
"Pressured by retailers and manufacturers, two major auction sites have changed their coupon policies. In October, Yahoo banned coupon sales. That increased pressure on eBay, as the Grocery Manufacturers of America and the Food Marketing Institute called on the site to follow Yahoo's example. In January, eBay bowed part way with a new policy banning the sale of expired or electronically delivered coupons. Its new rules also limit bulk sales and sales of free product and home-printed coupons. “Ideally, we would have liked for coupon auctions to be taken off totally, based on the argument that coupons are non-transferable intellectual property owned by the manufacturer, but we understand eBay's position,” says Karin Kroft, GMA's senior director of industry affairs. The GMA and other industry groups are working to make sure the policy results in real reform. The groups now scour the site for offending offerings and notify eBay when they find one."
If coupon auctions on Ebay are truly illegal, why wasn't the industry able to get Ebay to close down all of them? Why wasn't a law cited, instead of an "argument" made by the GMA?
From what I've read, the main coupon fraud problem the industry has is stores (or fake stores) turning in tons of coupons for products that were never bought. I don't think any of us are trying to do that. And if it's just that the companies don't want us using more than one or two coupons for a product, why is trading them any more legitimate than using a coupon service?