Home  Finance Articles  Discussion  Our Blog / Member Blogs         
SavingAdvice.com Logo The SavingAdvice.com millionaire calculator is a fun way to see how long it will take for YOU to become a millionaire.
Teaching you to Save Money

<< Blog Home

10 Reasons Not To Make New Year’s Resolutions This Year


new year resolutionsBy Jeffrey Strain

While I know you’re probably putting together a list of New Year’s resolutions if you haven’t done so yet, I would ask that you stop. Don’t even bother. Boycott the whole tradition. Refuse to get suckered into a yearly game that gives the impression that it will help, but actually does you more harm than good. How do New Year Resolutions hurt? Let me explain the ways:

First and foremost, New Year’s Resolutions are nothing more than a delay tactic — they are an easy way to delay something that you know you should be doing right when you decide that it should be done. If something is important enough to make a New Year’s Resolution about, then it’s something that is important enough to begin doing the minute you decide it’s that important. Learn to begin goals immediately once you have made the commitment to reach them rather than delaying them to some arbitrary date in the future.

Even worse, New Year’s Resolutions provide an easy cop-out. The problem is that most people never follow through with the New year’s Resolutions they make and everyone knows it. The result is that nobody will hold you to any resolutions you make because they don’t expect you to keep them. That means that at the first sign of difficulty, you are in an easy position to give up and nobody will say a thing. If you make solid goals, however, and announce them to friends and family not as New Year’s Resolutions, but as life changing goals, there is a completely different aspect to them. Especially if you ask for friends and family to support you in trying to reach them, it makes it much harder to quit and more likely you will work through those difficult stretches than if you simply make a resolution.

This leads to yet another problem of New Year’s resolutions which is that they are made without the proper preparation needed to succeed. The fact is, making changes to your life requires a lot of work, stamina and discipline to succeed. If you do not make the initial research and preparations on how you are going to make the goal succeed, you will likely never achieve it. Most New Year’s Resolutions are simply statements without any of the proper planning in place meaning that they are bound to fail.

When the proper planning hasn’t been done, New Year’s Resolutions are often unrealistic because they are so broad. Achieving goals is not an instantaneous result. You don’t get to the top of a mountain in a single step. It takes a lot of planning, effort and small steps along the way. No matter how much you wish, you aren’t gong to be able to wipe out all your credit card debt which has been building for years in a couple of months. You will need to work at it one step at a time chipping away at the debts one at a time. You would be much better off focusing on that first step toward the ultimate goal than the entire goal.

Another problem is New Years Resolutions tend to be absolute with little to no room for the obstacles that are bound to happen. This makes giving them up easy the first time an obstacle arises since they are often made as all or nothing statements where any deviation means you fail. Life, unfortunately, doesn’t make reaching goals without setbacks happening very often and why planning and taking small steps is so important. If there is no recourse on how to proceed when an obstacle occurs, then the goal will likely be abandoned instead.

Too many New Year’s Resolutions are also made for the wrong reasons. If you are 100% committed to accomplishing something, then it is a goal worth pursuing. If you are making a goal because it is something that you would like to change, but aren’t willing to put in the time and effort needed to make it happen, then it’s going to fail. For many, New year’s Resolutions are nothing more than things they wished they could change without having to make any effort. In order to succeed, you’ll need the passion that will only come from you firmly wanting to reach the goal. If you aren’t, it’s better not to make it until you are ready.

January is a terrible time to start your New Year’s Resolutions. Granted, there will likely never be a perfect time to begin, but the New Year can be one of the worst times to be making major changes. You’re tired after the holidays and instead of resting, you make drastic changes when you may not have the physical or psychological energy to make them work. Piling on resolutions with all of the other issues that need to be dealt with at the beginning of the New Year can make it that much harder for the goals to succeed.

This leads to another major problem which is that people make too many of New Year’s Resolutions all at the same time. Achieving the goal of getting your finances in order is a monumental task in itself, but making it work while losing 20 pounds, exercising an extra 2 hours a day, reorganizing your house and quiting smoking makes success impossible. It’s important to prioritize your goals and work on them as time permits rather than jumbling them all together at the beginning of the New Year.

Over time, New Years Resolutions have a negative impact on your motivation and success. When you make New Year’s Resolutions year after year and the resolutions fail year after year, it becomes easy to believe that the resolutions really can’t be accomplished. Instead of seeing that they have failed due to failing to take the proper steps to set the goals up, you only see failure time and again and many people simply give up on their goals entirely after awhile.

In the end, New Year’s Resolutions simply don’t work. Goals wrapped it up as New Year’s Resolutions lack the planning and commitment needed for them to work. If you have goals, take the proper steps of doing your research, setting up a step by step plan, measure your progress and make sure that you truly achieve what you set out to accomplish.

Here is a challenge you aren’t likely to see much at this time of year. I challenge you to not to make any New Year’s Resolutions for 2008. Instead, take the most important goals and begin laying the groundwork on how you can achieve them this very minute. That way when 2009 arrives, instead of rehashing the same New Year’s Resolution list you are currently thinking about, you will be checking off a list of goals that you accomplished in 2008.

Image courtesy of seeks2dream



Write a Comment

Take a moment to comment and tell us what you think. Some basic HTML is allowed for formatting.

Your Comment:

Reader Comments

My New Year’s Resolution is … to not make any more New Year’s Resolutions.

Last year I made a list of 11 Resolutions and stuck in front of my desk. The list haunted me all year.

I achieved only the very last Resolution: to lower my expectations of myself. Deep down I must have known I was being completely unrealistic!

Good post. I am a very goal driven person, but I never make New YEars’ resolutions. I just never saw the point. I set goals as I Feel the need.

& it’s generally easy to tackle one small thing at a time then to set a bunch of resolutions at once.

I like resolutions.
I achieve a few every year. This year I completed:
1)Have a wedding
2)Max out my ROTH (recurrent one),
3)Visit new country (1 month min), also recurrent
5)get a promotion

I have a few that I did not accomplish and will try again.
I also have few new goals.
New Year is like a fresh start, and while it may be arbitrary, nonetheless it is a nice feeling.

Another twist on the “too many people make NY resolutions at the same time”. Often, the social structures that can help you succeed in your goals are also overworked, or they understand the game of resolutions, so they don’t waste their time on you.

For example, take the resolution of losing weight/getting physically fit. My first visit to a gym and to a trainer was in November. I could establish a good relationship with the trainer and gym because very few new people came & the trainers were hungry for new people. Great customer service! Fast forward to January and the gym’s busy season – the trainer literally told me to sit tight & and if they all seemed a little short it was because they were working the “resolution crowd” who would be gone by February. They’ll do what they can, but you’ll be taken seriously only if you stay through February.

Call me an idealist, but I sort of like New Year’s resolutions.

Sure, most resolutions are probably broken, but that doesn’t mean that they’re not worth making. And New Years gives us a good excuse to sit down and think about what we want to — and can — change.

If you know you’re not good at resolutions, then think small. Resolutions don’t have to be drastic, life changing decisions.

If you’re curious, you can read some of my resolutions here: http://fashion.thebargainqueen.com/2007/12/start-your-new-year-right/

True but cynical. Don’t hate the game…. hate the player.

The day we quit resolving to change is the day we quit. We need to encourage people more throughout the year. Ask people how their resolutions are going. Hold them more accountable. Not accomplishing all your resolutions doesn’t mean failure…. quitting does.

I’ve learned to make realistic resolutions.

my new year’s resolution is to become morbidly obese, start smoking, and get 17 cavities.

Now those are some new year’s resolutions that I will feel great about failing!

Don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater! Just because most people go about making new years resolutions the wrong way doesn’t mean that the practice of making them is wrong!

Many people tend to see new years resolutions as an all-or-none phenomenon–”once I blow the diet, I might as well give up because I’ve failed.” That’s the wrong way to go about it. The New Years Resolution is the destination, and like all good journeys, you’ll get there more efficiently if you have a roadmap, or plan. Also, there might be some detours and backtracking along the way, but that doesn’t mean that you should give up on going where you planned.

For some recent research on factors predicting success at keeping new years resolutions, see the article about Dr. Richard Wiseman’s research at http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2007/dec/28/sciencenews.research

Did you actually read the article or is your response to just the title? He never says to “throw out the baby with the bathwater” – he said you should go about making them in a way that gives you a better chance to achieve them since there are problems the way most people make resolutions.

I almost always make resolutions, and almost always forget all about them by February. For me, the best reason not to make resolutions is the way they make me act before the new year actually begins. I’ve been eating like a complete pig during the last few weeks because I know January is coming and I’m planning on cutting back starting on 1/1/08. However, I do enjoy the clean slate feeling that comes with a new year, and even if I only diet for a few weeks, that’s better than nothing, right? That will at least help me undo the damage I did in December. :)

[...] Saving Advice turns conventional wisdom on its head and lists ten reasons not to make New Year’s Resolutions. [...]

Way too realistic… where’s the post making me feel good about setting tons of goals?!?!

I agree that New Year’s resolutions often lack the planning and commitment. I’ve made a few commitments with barely a thought behind them… or it was the alcohol talking by midnight.

According to the American Psychological Association (APA), the most popular New Year’s resolutions are losing weight, quitting smoking, and exercising more regularly. Unfortunately, almost sixty percent of those who make resolutions give up, within the first six months. Nevertheless, chances are that if one does make a resolution, one will be ten times more likely to prevail over those without the resolve.

Our feelings actually dictate our actions. In that regard, if your reader’s are like most people (including myself), they probably have brand name toothpaste at home. Although we intellectually know that generic toothpaste is basically the same as (and generally less expensive than) the brand name, we pay more for the brand name, because we feel that it will provide us with “fresher breath and whiter teeth.”

Advertisers tend to trick our emotional selves into feeling good about their product over their competitors’ or generic, often causing us to change our behavior to spend more for their product. Using this same basic “Psych 101″ principle to one’s advantage, can help empower oneself to create positive change, especially as it applies to resolutions.

To succeed with resolutions, therefore, it is vital to pair enough emotional pain to the old behaviors, and enough emotional pleasure with the new behaviors. For example, instead of simply criticizing oneself for jeopardizing one’s health and wealth, a smoker might imagine how good it will feel to breathe easier as well as to have more energy, freedom and pride in the accomplishment.

Very good! The New Year’s Resolution tradition defies one of the key ways to make certain goals are actually met … do them because they are IMPORTANT TO YOU, rather than societally expected. There’s the first “duh.” How many people will ask you, throughout the month of January: “What are your New Year’s Resolutions?” After 51 years of hearing that, I’m inclined, this January to respond “To not call you an ignorant and interferingly rude imbecile for even asking … OOPS! Blew it!” But then … its a difficult morning. I plan to NOT resolve anything this New Year’s Eve. The images of curling up before a warm fire, knowing that the harvest is in and that this is a time of quiet reflection and warm fuzzy feelings is hardly apt in today’s complex (and largely non-agrarian) United States, and the fallacy of the contemplative process needed for true reflection begins to fall apart there. Thank you for this highly supportive and very sensible article!



Apply for a £1000 loan | UK iva Resource | IVA Help

About Us | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Link To Us | Resources | Webmasters | Media | Jobs | Site Map | Contact Us

Copyright ©2002-2009 SavingAdvice.com. All rights reserved.

Please read our Disclaimer

  Partners
Debt Reduction
Blogging Away Debt
Budget Stretcher
DivaTribe
Thrifty Fun
Money Talk
Online Personal Budgeting
Budget Dial
Admin